Trump’s Speech: the Immigration Points

Published on March 1st, 2017

By Joe Guzzardi
March 1, 2017
President Donald Trump’s rousing address to a joint session of Congress reinforced his image as a leader who will put Americans’ interests first, and it offered a much-needed helping hand to the nation’s vulnerable workers.
As expected, President Trump talked about immigration. For the first time in decades, however, a sitting president linked high immigration levels to American job loss and stagnant wages. The chief executive said that the outdated legal immigration system has hurt employed and unemployed Americans. Every year for at least the last two decades, an average of one million employment-authorized legal immigrants come to the U.S. – a minimum of 20 million new workers have been added to the labor force in the last 20 years. Trump wants merit-based immigration similar to that in Australia and Canada.
According to the Department of Homeland Security, in 2015 from the more than one million legal immigrants who arrived, two-thirds entered on family-preference and not skill-based visas. President Trump cited the National Academy of Sciences which found that admitting lower-skilled immigrants through chain migration costs taxpayers “many billions of dollars a year,” and depresses wages for the poorest workers. Flooding the labor pool with the unskilled has, for example, dramatically affected those with only a high school education. Census Bureau research showed that in 2000, 66 percent of high school grads were employed; by 2015, the total had dropped to 53 percent. In short, immigration creates more job competition for less-skilled, less-educated Americans.
For immigration advocates, President Trump’s speech disappointed. In the hours leading up to his address, President Trump met with news anchors who came away with the impression that his administration might be open to comprehensive immigration reform, code talk for amnesty. But President Trump’s actual remarks were sufficiently vague – “real and positive immigration reform is possible” – that hopes were dashed.
Instead, President Trump reiterated his determination to deport criminal aliens, protect the interior from “lawless chaos” and move ahead on the border wall. Family members whose loved ones were murdered by illegal immigrants applauded the president’s speech. President Trump’s base expects him to keep his September campaign pledge that for those who entered the U.S. illegally, citizenship or permanent residency will be impossible.
The president scored points on infrastructure construction, beefing up the military and tax reform, as well as repealing and replacing Obamacare. But on three immigration-related subjects, President Trump remained disappointingly silent. First, he’s apparently reneged on his campaign promise to stop issuing new work permits to President Obama’s deferred action for childhood arrivals, and has continued to approve thousands of renewals. The DACAs compete with Americans for jobs.
Second, instead of a wall, President Trump should urge Congress to pass mandatory E-Verify which would ensure that only citizens and legal immigrants could hold jobs. The Pew Research Center estimates that 7 million illegal immigrants are employed in non-farm jobs. Third, Trump should also encourage Congress to review birthright citizenship. A law must be passed that citizenship cannot be conferred at birth unless at least one parent is a citizen or a legal resident. Currently, any mother who gives birth, even if she has only been in the U.S. for a few hours, will have delivered a citizen child who will reap citizenship’s benefits throughout his lifetime.
My grade for Trump’s speech: A for what he said; F, for what he omitted.

A Californians for Population Stabilization Senior Writing Fellow, Joe’s email address is [email protected]. Find him on Twitter @joeguzzardi19.

You are donating to :

How much would you like to donate?
$10 $20 $30
Would you like to make regular donations? I would like to make donation(s)
How many times would you like this to recur? (including this payment) *
Name *
Last Name *
Email *
Additional Note