Less immigration means more American jobs, higher wages

Published on August 7th, 2017

Joe Guzzardi
August 7, 2017
As seen in:
Jackson Sun
Pocono Record
USA Today

More than half a century after the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, and 30 years after the Immigration Reform and Control Act, U.S. Senators Tom Cotton (R-AR) and David Perdue (R-GA) introduced a sensible merit-based bill that will help all Americans. 

The Reforming American Immigration for a Strong Economy Act, or RAISE Act, proposes to cut legal immigration roughly in half, from one million new arrivals annually to about 500,000, and would screen them on a points-based system similar to Canada and Australia for skills, education and English language ability. In the process, the RAISE Act would mostly eliminate the haphazard chain migration system that allows family members to petition their adult siblings, adult sons and adult daughters, who in turn can bring their own relatives, and create an endless incoming immigrant stream.

Under the RAISE Act, only nuclear family members could be admitted. In addition to tightening up immigration entry standards, the proposed legislation would eliminate the outdated and pointless Diversity Visa lottery — the random admission of 50,000 immigrants — and mandate a maximum refugee resettlement total of 50,000 per year, instead of allowing the president to decide what cap, if any, should be imposed.

Those are the RAISE Act’s bare bones, but the proposed legislation represents a much-needed boost to unemployed, underemployed and employed Americans whose wages have been frozen for years. Referencing studies from Harvard and Princeton, Cotton and Perdue say legal immigration would be cut by RAISE in the first year by 41 percent — from roughly 1.1 million to 637,960 — and to 539,958 by the 10th year, for a 50 percent decline. And the resulting tighter labor market would mean more Americans would fill jobs and wages would rise, the indisputable effects of supply and demand economics.

In his opening statements, which he delivered from the White House, President Trump said the current immigration policy has placed “substantial pressure on American workers, taxpayers and community resources,” and, most importantly, is unfair to minority workers who compete for jobs with recently arrived immigrants. The RAISE Act would, said President Trump, put American families first.

Congressional Democrats, the media and advocacy groups quickly went on attack mode. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) charged President Trump with pursuing a hateful, senseless anti-immigrant agenda. CNN reporter Jim Acosta charged that RAISE isn’t in keeping with Statue of Liberty values. And ITI, a technology industry trade group, claimed the bill would impede Silicon Valley’s ability to compete globally — false, predictable, knee-jerk statements that don’t stand up to rational thought. The truth is, after more than 50 years of immigration continuing on autopilot — and regardless of 9/11, recessions, mortgage meltdowns or soaring city and state populations — a congressional debate is very overdue.


You are donating to :

How much would you like to donate?
$10 $20 $30
Would you like to make regular donations? I would like to make donation(s)
How many times would you like this to recur? (including this payment) *
Name *
Last Name *
Email *
Additional Note